[CH3:1][C:2]1([CH3:9])[C:7](=[O:8])[C:5](=[O:6])[O:4][CH2:3]1.[H][H]>C1COCC1>[CH3:1][C:2]1([CH3:9])[C@@H:7]([OH:8])[C:5](=[O:6])[O:4][CH2:3]10.0025 m-mole of rhodium-1,5-cyclooctadienechloride complex and 0.0065 m-mole of one of the asymmetric ligand compounds indicated in Table 2 were dissolved in 10 ml of THF, and 5 m-mole of ketopantolactone was added thereto. Reduction was carried out at a hydrogen atmosphere of 50 atm. The mixture was stirred at 50° C. for 45 hours. The reaction mixture was concentrated under reduced pressure and distilled under reduced pressure to obtain optically active (R)-(-)pantolactone. The results are shown in Table 2.